The end of IBKR + VT: a cheaper, safer, less US-dependent alternative

Didn’t swap cost like 10-20bps? Which is roughly equal to the tax drag on IE UCITS.

If going for UCITS is your objecive, not sure if it’s worth optimizing for that last 10bps (variation in indeed choice will have more impact).

Maybe depends if you’d rather have your money go to a bank or to the US gov :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

2 Likes

That’s what I thought as well, but I assume it’s a figure for highly liquid markets only.

At the end of the day, it should be baked into the NAV. It turns out that (from trackingdifferences.com’s live table) I don’t see an obvious edge of synthetic EM funds.

Fund Replication Domicile TER TD (avg)
Amundi Core MSCI EM Physical LU 0.18% 0.20%
Amundi MSCI EM Synthetic LU 0.20% 0.28%

Yes, I totally agree.

But again I am uneasy about one-fund synthetic solutions, especially now that Scalable MSCI AC World Leveraged Daily Swap UCITS has been registered with Luxembourg regulators :sweat_smile:

It is actually a good question. Ideally, money ends up in my pocket but otherwise, in order of priority, I’d rather see it reach the Swiss tax system, then EU tax systems, and eventually foreign private companies as long as they do not blatantly contribute to killing people.

In any case, I do not want my money to be thrown over the middle east while increasing Lockheed Martin’s dividend yield - and burning human flesh :worried:

Gerd Kommer’s ETF can be a one-fund solution if the things he’s incorporated are similar to one’s own preferences: 1% cap for a single stock, country weights based on 50% market cap / 50% GDP, delayed inclusion of IPOs, small caps, multi-factor. Only thing that hurts is the TER of 0.45%.

I like the idea, but 45 bps is indeed hard to justify given costs of roughly comparable products: The newly launched L&G WTW Global Equity Diversified is 19 bps.

I learned from this table that the maximum fee, after promotion period, cannot be higher than 0.12% as shown in the sub-fund prospectus.

I like this table because it also shows very cleary the measurable voting behaviour and responsible investment practices of Asset Managers.

As expected, European providers score incomparably better than American ones.

Interestingly, for me the way how Vanguard votes (conservative, shareholder first) is a non-financial preference for them.

I know. For other people, Amundi’s strict group-wide mandate banning companies linked to cluster munitions, landmines, biological/chemical weapons, or nuclear weapon components outside the Non-Proliferation Treaty plays on the asset manager’s favour.

These are legal obligations under French law. I believe they apply to every Amundi or BNP Paribas vehicle without exception, including standard index trackers. Excluded issuers are flagged in the portfolio management system with pre-trade blocking in the compliance tool.

Interestingly, women seem to be overrepresented in this category of retail investors. Coincidentally, Amundi’s CEO is a woman.

Many people don’t want to be involved in, or benefit from, trade of weapons banned by international treaties for being particularly inhumane. Norway’s sovereign fund, the largest shareholder in the world, also excludes nuclear-weapon producers such as Lockheed, Northrop and General Dynamics.

The effects of social norms on markets were explained in this paper: Journal of Financial Economics.

Europe can be a massive player in the financial industry, and move the needle in a significant way at the global scale. For example, and following a pull back from ESG across US financial institutions, State Street was bruised by this 35bn divestment:
https://sustainabilitymag.com/articles/why-state-street-lost-us-35bn-to-amundi-invesco-over-esg

I maintain that the most useful way to deploy capital on the public stock market for ESG purposes is to concentrate it in the sinners and get a board seat. Then force the rest of the capital to implement low-cost, high-ESG-return measures, and use the proof of concept to lobby for laws forcing competitors to do the same.

See:

1 Like

Imho what Amundi is doing is borderline fraudulent and this very much feels fishy. If you have an ESG tilt towards a political ideal, then so be it - just market it as an ESG fund or even just ESG tilted fund. I for one prefer a neutral index, without any judgement or bias.

And on a personal note - call me heartless - the only thing I care about is return on investment, not ESG criteria.

1 Like

FYI many parts of ESG are about return on investment. (depending on the flavor)

E.g. governance and adaptation to climate risk are very much impactful.

1 Like

They have to respect laws and regulations.

Knowingly providing direct or indirect financial support to the manufacture or trade of cluster munitions would constitute assistance, encouragement or inducement caught by the criminal provisions.

See Code de la défense, Partie 2, Livre III, Titre IV “Armes soumises à interdiction”.

I do care about my return on investment, and it served me very well, so far :innocent:

(Note: I am indeed moving away from US ISINs like USXF to UCITS equivalents)

For me WEBG is totally fine. It serves the objective of investing in a large bunch of companies located globally at low cost. If they omit certain companies , it’s not the end of the world for me.

And that’s great - I just want it to be declared… if Amundi is doing that, they shouldn’t be allowed to market it as a pure index fund.

(the outperformance comes from overweighting tech, not from making the world better imho).

If Rheinmetall or Lockhead Martin would raise to an Nvidea size, no one would say this… I just want transparency, so that people who don’t want to fund ESG investment can do so, transparently. (I do have my own oppinion on it and it’s not positive, but that’d be something to talk about over a beer, not in this forum).

5 Likes

Happy to meet up for such a beer :clinking_beer_mugs:

Studies demonstrate quite the opposite: People actually do care. See Journal of Financial Economics.
I would still feel strongly about financing “controversial” weaponery, and it would still be illegal to do so under many legislations in this part of the world.

We have social norms; these companies seem to attract a special kind of people, serving a special kind of purpose. (Obviously, the company didn’t bother to take a stance.).

We also have a strong Swiss humanitarian tradition, fundamentally opposed to “controversial” weaponry. No one is forcing us to move away from civilized values, or to submit to Trump’s view of the world.

You are allowed to be foreign and/or to have different values. My point is that we do have European providers, abiding by European laws and values, that can also be better and cheaper than US providers.

This sounds like revisionist history (to me)… We mainly have a tradition in trading with super powers in war to our own benefit - which I personally think is and was a brilliant wealth kickstarter, but that’s neither here nor there.

Yes, and all of that is not really relevant in terms of passive investing - it by definition means to decouple ones personal moral beliefs and ideals in order to make bank and let the market decide.

Note: I don’t have anything against companies offering ESG funds (as long as I’m not to forced to invest in them), all I care about in the case of Amundi is that claiming to replicate an index, but then stating in fine print that you can’t invest in lockhead martin (But ofc european weapon manufacturers are okay - lol) is hypocritical protectionist nonsense imho.

Yes, by lying / disguising their political ideological bias, which is what I critisized. Also what does “be foreign” mean? I’m a Swiss person…

The TER difference between a 0.2% and a 0.05% fund is not going to make or break your FIRE journey anyway, so sure - from that standpoint you’re right. VWRL/VWRD will now be 0.14% - still 2x VT, but for all intents and purposes irrelevant.

2 Likes

I do believe the nuclear wapons will kill us all eventually. A nuclear war is a low probability event, but even a low probability event in infinite time is a sure thing. We traded the certainty of repeated conventional wars for a probability of total destruction.

That said, i am fine with profiting from the manufacturers of nuclear weapons (Airbus of France for instance, IIRC they have a finger in the business). We need a world agreement on banning them, however far away it seems now.

For the cluster munitions, ask Ukrainians if they would use them. They will. War is not something where you can play with hands tied by conventions. If you can deploy even controversial weapons to survive, you will.

1 Like

What’s your estimate for this eventually?

As s Swiss, I agree with @Akia that this is a myth, very good for business, which would not hold up to scrutiny.

I’m still missing the proof for this claim.

It’s impossible to estimate using statistics. You don’t need my guess, as it is as good as anyone else’s.