Splitting LPP into two vested benefits pots when leaving an employer: does this actually work?

Some background: I’m planning a fairly big buy-back into my second pillar, and I also expect to be changing jobs before too long and want to optimise the 2nd Pillar funds now while I can.

I rang Finpension to ask. Their answer was that the mandatory part has to go into your new employer’s LPP, but the extra-mandatory part can stay in a vested benefits account. Their recommendation was to split the termination benefit into two vested benefits pots when you leave, one mandatory and one extra-mandatory. When you start the new job you transfer only the mandatory pot, and the extra-mandatory stays where you put it.

I also called my own LPP provider and they confirmed I can split it into two parts.

So the mechanics seem to be there, but before I rely on it, has anyone here actually done it?

1 Like

You can split it into 2 parts, but I’m not sure whether you can really ‘allocate’ mandatory to one or the other. And I think you’re supposed to transfer all accounts to the new employer, although some people deliberately only transfer part to leave the other part invested.

As far as I know, the pension fund decides what kind of splits are possible. Some pension funds may keep the ratio of mandatory and extra-mandatory the same for the two parts while others may allow splitting along the mandatory/extra-mandatory line. There may also be other options, I’m not familiar with the details.

Yes, that’s correct.

The federal council wanted to enforce moving of vested benefits to pension funds together with an improvement of 1e plans. However, on Sep 2, the commission decided to separate the two changes. There may still be enforcement at some point in the future but probably not that soon.

6 Likes

I guess might depend also how the Nationalrat sees it (I assume they can reintroduce it). Might be seen too much as a gift for highly paid people already.

3 Likes

By the way also be careful, if you don’t transfer everything it becomes easier to mess things up (e.g. buy-in when not allowed, etc.).

2 Likes

I did exactly that split. They (Axa) gave me a form where i could exactly define how i want to split the money (fully flexible across mandatory and extra). I put it to finpension and viac.
I understand its important that you have a gap between employments to be eligible to transfer to vested benefit accounts and do the split.

I also researched a bit to find out why this split model exists in the first place. Apparently cash positions in vested benefit accounts are not insured. So if the organization goes bankrupt they are at risk. Thats why they allowed to spread this risk over multiple vested benefit accounts.
I think you could also split further once leaving the next job and end up with >2 accounts. Which can be advantageous when paying them out before retirement.

As mentioned above there are political efforts to limit or close down this approach.

3 Likes

Pillar 2 and 1e may also be separate funds and so each can be split in 2, so after leaving an employer you could potentially split into 4 funds.

4 Likes

Indeed, this has also been my experience. When I requested my pension fund to split into two parts, there was no option for me to chose where the mandatory part went. The pension fund simply applied the ratio I had between mandatory and extra-mandatory for both amounts I asked them to split my funds into.

3 Likes

Same here.

1 Like

The law does not restrict pension funds how they allow to split. Any split is legally allowd to max to vested accounts.

So I guess its matter if they want to allow you this or just apply there standard approach. Axa also told me that i could not split as I d like which the was adjusted when I insisted. But guess it comes down to the individual fund.

I posted similar today on Reddit forum, and someone comment “I asked VIAC the same today and they told me this as well. Should have splitted it when I left the employer. They are forced to transfer everything when joining a new pension fund. So maybe I’ll try the “I forgot to transfer the money” way and see where it leads”.

you can only split when leaving a pension fund. not when leaving a vested benefits foundation.

VIAC has 1 vested benefits foundation. The split (mandatory and non-mandatory) shown as 2 separate accounts in VIAC are 1 single pot of money that VIAC has to transfer together whenever you request them to transfer to a pension fund or another vested benefits foundation.

when leaving your pension fund you can split the money in 2 parts and choose 2 separate foundations as destination: VIAC VB, FP VB 1, FP VB 2, Frankly VB 1, Frankly VB 2, etc, etc.

From then on, the pots will remain separate, till you instruct the VB foundations to transfer them to you pension fund.

6 Likes

Maybe clever, but wrong. Or simply misunderstood.

You have to transfer everthing - mandatory and non-mandatory parts to your new employers pension fund. Up to that pension fund’s maximum buy-in - an amount set by its regulations (for your plan and age), which may and usually do well exceed the legally required minimum. Once you fully bought into your new employer’s fund though, any excess amount goes (stays) on a vesting account.

7 Likes

Are the rules for all of this written somewhere?

The legal framework is pretty clear. You can’t leave money in a VB unless you’re above the limit on the new pension fund.

Whether it’s enforced is another question.

(edit: fixed link, was a link to the Dittli-related proposal, linked to the current version)

4 Likes

Exactly, the current law has no enforcable punishment attached (german: nicht strafbewehrtt). So the new pensionfund can ask you to do it but has no lever to enforce it. Thats the grey zone in the current law.

1 Like

This isn’t incorrect, but it also isn’t the whole picture. Which vested benefits have to be transferred to your new employer’s pension fund depends on the terms and conditions of your new pension plan.

The general rule is always: Vested benefits must be transferred to your new employer’s pension fund.

There are exceptional cases in which your new pension plan is not fully compatible with your existing extra-obligatory benefits. That may be the case if, for example, you had a 1e plan with your last pension fund, and your new pension fund does not offer 1e plans. In that case, some extra-obligatory benefits may have to remain vested. But this is the absolute exception.

You can, of course, split your pension fund benefits between two vested benefits foundations. This can have tax advantages if you plan to withdraw your benefits while they are vested. But it has no bearing whatsoever on which portion of vested benefits must be transferred to your new pension fund.

That’s not directly related, is it? The 1e or early-retire buy-ins will just merge with the other extra-obligatory pot in those cases.
What is relevant is if your assets exceed your new p2’s max buy-in, in which case you’d be allowed or required to take the excess out.

In general, while I’m not opposed to take advantage of the current enforcement of of the law, I think it doesn’t reflect well on Finpension as financial service provider to state or advertise the rules like that to potential customers.

For the anecdotes, my previous pension fund also insisted on splitting the mandatory part in equal portions.
That said, splitting mandatory and extra-mandatory only seems relevant when receiving a pension with a split conversation rates, and in some cases for withdrawing abroad.

Whether the excess is derived from extra-obligatory contributions via your previous employer or from buy-ins is not really important. Both are extra-obligatory. It’s a question of how extra-obligatory benefits figure into your new pension fund/plan.

In short, there is no way that the OP can know whether or not part of their benefits can/must remain vested until they begin their next employment with a Swiss employer.

In every case, vested benefits must always be transferred to a new pension fund in full. The new pension fund will inform you about what happens next.

1 Like