Rental guarantee deposit vs. insurance

Never saw it discussed here, so I was wondering: how do you do it?

My rental guarantee is currently 2360 CHF and I never had a deposit since I moved out of my parents place, always went with the insurance. AXA is basically the cheapest option out there as almost everyone is asking for 5%/year and often double for the 1st year.

So I’m paying 89.30 CHF per year for this insurance. Or in other words it’s costing me 3.78%/year. For me it’s a no-brainer because the expected return of my investments is higher than that and I don’t like to have blocked money.

These days, with interest rates close to nothing, it would make sense.

Just checked and Raiffeisen gives you a whopping 0.025% for the Mieterkautionssparkonto.

Would you take a margin loan at that rate ? I personnaly wouldn’t. Maybe borrow money at 1.5% and use it for a deposit.

I’ve got a conventional rental deposit account. In my mind it was : “I just need to put my security deposit somewhere”.

I’m not a fan of insurance or other financial instrument as “First Caution” or “Swiss Caution” as I don’t know how many year I’ll stay in my current flat ; I’m fine to have “money block”.

I also have private liability and household insurance with them, so I just see the whole thing as an yearly insurance cost of 360 CHF. I know 3.8% margin rate doesn’t sound great, but it makes it very convenient.

The yearly rate is calculated on a daily basis. So if you move out and don’t need it anymore, you get the rest back.

One interesting question would also be: can you switch from having an account to having an insurance policy? And the other way.

This is just credit at 4-5%

Why not borrow from IB at 1.5% instead. No-brainer, no?

Don’t forget that many places doesn’t allow an insurance.

By reading and partipating to this forum, you confirm you have read and agree with the disclaimer presented on
En lisant et participant à ce forum, vous confirmez avoir lu et être d'accord avec l'avis de dégagement de responsabilité présenté sur