I am looking for some critical feedback on my couple’s financial situation.
Our profile:
Working couple, early 30s.
Income: CHF 6,000 gross per month each.
Main goal: We want to save up a down payment to buy a property within the next 5 years (wishful thinking ).
The issue:
We made the classic beginner’s mistake of trusting an advisor from SVAG in July 2026.
As a result, we ended up with a stack of highly aggressive, fee-heavy products which, after doing some research (too late), seem completely disconnected from our short-term real estate project.
Here is the setup the advisor opened for us:
3a Insurance (mixed): My boyfriend signed with Swiss Life a year ago, with monthly premiums of CHF 300. The current surrender value is CHF 1,900. As for me, I signed with Pax in July through SVAG, but I haven’t paid any premiums yet.
For both of us – 3a Bank account with investment funds (Zugerberg/Zweisplus): 2% fee per deposit and 1.5% annual management fee, very aggressive risk profile.
For both of us – A “Revo5” product (via Bank Zweiplus / Zugerberg Finanz): Same risk profile as the 3a bank account.
What raised red flags for me:
He also opened a separate disability/death insurance policy with monthly premiums of CHF 200. On top of that, he advised me to use the remaining money from my student loan to invest in the high-risk Revo5 fund account. I felt very uncomfortable investing money that doesn’t belong to me into the stock market…
From what I have researched so far, this investment strategy seems way too risky for short-term savings. Also, I understand that banks apply a significant haircut (déquote) on this type of risky savings when assessing a mortgage request… but I am no expert!
Our questions to the community:
General thoughts: What do you think of this overall situation?
Exit strategy for 3a insurance: Since the contracts are less than a year old (or just about a year), do you confirm it is better to purely cancel the 3a insurance (even if it means losing the first year’s premiums) rather than putting it on hold?
Revo5 and Zweisplus 3a bank account: Is it possible to transfer the 3a bank account directly to a clean, low-cost provider like Finpension or Viac without heavy exit fees? How do we properly liquidate the Revo5 account?
Allocation for the property project (5 years): How should we allocate our monthly savings on such a short horizon? Should we favor short-term bonds, cash accounts, or a very conservative 3a bank strategy (cash/bonds)?
Thanks a lot in advance for your help in cleaning this up!
I would cancel everything, take the money lost; it least you learned something.
How far away are you from being able to buy a home? If in the next 5 years you are able to get there with your actual cash and extra saving, I would put everything into a savings account and wait until then. You savings should be higher than the real estate appreciation though. If you are more than 5 years away or don’t know, I would invest everything into world etf allocation (max 3a viac/finpension; rest into 3b like Vwra/Vall), save and invest your savings and assess again when you get close to it.
The first thing to do is to stop contributing new money to the 3a insurance black hole. At least you are not making it worse while you are figuring out the next steps.
As for the death and disability, do your employers not offer this within the 2nd pillar? If they do, and unless you have a very real reason why you need a supplemental insurance, I would look into the conditions to cancel. The 200/mo is a sizable part of your monthly savings that you could put to a better use.
“1. General thoughts: What do you think of this overall situation?”
For your specific financial goals (buying a house in around 5 years), it’s a very sub-optimal setup.
I would advise you to withdraw from all of those contracts. None of them are suitable or necessary for a 5-year home purchase sprint.
For a 5-year sprint, just using the highest-yield savings account or medium-term notes is the most sensible option. If you are willing to accept some risk of loss for potential higher returns, you could invest 10 or 20 percent in a diversified investment portfolio.
There’s no harm in using the pillar 3a for part of the savings, in order to claim the tax benefits. But unless you do not have a pension fund, the low limit for contributions will make it a drop in the down payment bucket.
Buying a home within 5 years is not wishful thinking at all. With 12K gross per month between you, putting aside just 6K a month towards your new home is quite realistic. That would take you to 360K in 5 years without taking on any investment risk or even earning any interest. Add to that some interest/returns, and you will easily cover a down payment and then some.
According to our advisor there would be a loss of 1500 chf in case of disability, so he subscribed this to make us benefit from 600 chf more. But this contract does not seem at all optimal for our savings objective
Once you own a house, you could consider getting pure term life insurance and/or disability insurance to protect the mortgage payments & renovations in the case that one of you dies or becomes disabled. But as mentioned above, that is only necessary if your occupational pension plans do not already include supplementary life and disability insurance.
For your current goal of buying your own home, unnecessary insurance is just an extra expense.
If the person who set up these products for you is a qualified financial advisor, and it was clear that your goal was to save for a home with a savings/investment term of 5 years, then I would dare say they are highly incompetent. If they are just a salesperson…well…who can blame them for trying to make a sale.
When it comes to money, it’s often best to keep things simple. Avoid products you don’t understand, and the salespeople who push them.
Your advisor will request to not cancel and not stop the monthly deposit.
You should look at the term of your contract to cancel everything and send a recommended letter asap.
Very disturbing method to recruit young , uninformed student just out of Uni to gain their fatty bonus.
Regarding your income: good.
Regarding your expenses/savings: unknown.
Regarding your savings/investing setup: inadequate. Early enough to be corrected without meaningful consequences on your financial situation (but you have probably lost a few unrecoverable thousands or more and should be ready for it psychologically).
They are suboptimal for your stated goal (and most if not all goals, actually). They will stay suboptimal in the future. Keeping them just increases the difference vs an optimal-ish solution, a.k.a. the loss.
Unless there is a legal recourse to void the contract (there may be if you have been mislead or lied to by the seller, I have very little knowledge on the matter), the loss has already happened. Cutting your costs now is the quickest way to a better financial future.
It is possible. You may incur exit fees depending on the vehicles they’ve invested in (it’s still worth it). Both VIAC and Finpension provide a form for requesting the transfer of the funds to the old provider. Download it, sign it, send it. Done. If they try to convince you to keep your assets with them, you don’t have to. If they balance the prospect of incurring fees and not having as many assets as a consequence of changing provider, those fees would be quickly overcome by the difference between their humongous fees and those from another provider.
For a 5 years term horizon, cash or medium term notes (the money can’t be withdrawn and becomes illiquid for the duration of the note so you’d have to be sure you’d not want to buy the house in a shorter timeframe nor use the funds for another purpose).
For the money needed for the 10% hard assets, I’d go with 3a account(s) (0% stocks allocation) and savings accounts when maxed.
For the money not needed for the 10% hard assets (that can come from the second pillar): for the first 2 years, 2nd pillar buybacks might be interesting for the tax savings and potential higher interests vs a savings account. There’s a 3 years lockup period so you might want to avoid doing buybacks 3 years before you expect to do the purchase.
If you plan on using 2nd pillar assets for the purchase, it’s usually better to use the assets of only one person (if they’re not both needed) so that tax deductible buybacks can still be made to the account of the 2nd person. That’s provided you are married and assets would be divided fairly between the partners in case of divorce.
Professional advise only makes sense once you reach a certain level of wealth. Otherwise, the fees for a good investment advice will eat up all your savings.
If you are willing to spend some time, feel free to stick around in this form and ask questions here. (Edit: removed 'and maybe get some slack when asking (supposedly) stupid questions’.)
Alternatively, read up on websites such as MP and Poor Swiss to follow a diy approach.
Another alternative, consider using robo advisors (see mp and poor swiss) as a middle ground between diy and professional investment advice.
For the 3a account, just cancel and instruct them to transfer to your new 3a provider (Some even provide transfer cancellation/forms to make it easy for you). No more difficult than closing a bank account and instructing the bank to transfer the remaining balance elsewhere.
Regarding that (non-3a?) Revo5… no idea. Never heard about it. Surely you read the contract and cancellation terms before signing up and investing, especially since you felt uncomfortable about it to begin with!?
If it’s just one year, I wouldn’t even think about maintaining it. I’d cancel, even if it’s just
out of spite or
for the mental hygiene, closure and peace of mind of being done with such a crappy product and not being reminded about it later.
Mit dem Lesen und der Teilnahme an diesem Forum bestätigst du, dass du die Forum-Richtlinien gelesen hast und damit einverstanden bist sowie den Haftungsausschluss auf http://www.mustachianpost.com/de/ akzeptierst.