But using a European broker doesn’t save you from the paperwork. You might be able to get the funds released earlier, but you’d still need to file the paperwork.
Let’s move this discussion to the dedicated thread, please ![]()
That’s true
Just send them a note that you’re willing to pay the minimal custody fee (CHF 50 per quarter) or else … (IBKR).
Worked for me.
I’d rather have the 200 bucks for myself and say, spend it on a nice dinner, than sending the 200 bucks up Marc Bürki’s esteemed behind – after all, he’s already garnering over a million CHF for his SQ CEO gig.
YMMV, of course.
Aren’t these 200.- tax-deductible and therefore partially recoverable as a tax deduction?
Dinner is served !
I’ve been reading here and there that it’s possible to negotiate the spreads with Swissquote. However, I imagine that requires a certain track record and/or a significant amount to be considered. What have been the members’ experiences with Swissquote’s support on this matter?
I was watching https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9JW8UsQFjAs (which actually seems to be a pretty good run through of how to file form 706-NA by a lawyer).
At the end there were mention to the filing stats (sadly not updated in a while): SOI Tax Stats - Nonresident alien estate tax returns | Internal Revenue Service
In 2014, there were 660 treaty filing and 214 non-treaty filing total. Non surprisingly, people file more when they don’t have tax to pay as well
(most of the treaty declaration don’t have any tax to pay).
I strongly suspect as has been discussed a few times that the only case when people file is when there’s a US broker involved (or they own US real estate).
There’s probably a lot more people who die every year with 60k+ of AAPL or other US blue chip stock…
edit: and yeah seems like ~half of the filing involve US real estate ownership (which is a case where you really can’t avoid filing)
Does it Imply that people pay Estate tax as they dont ask for waiver or they simply don’t have such assets ?
As the number seems low
IMO it means that people don’t file unless they’re obliged to (ie cant access the estate without filing).
US real estate / US brokers would be majority of the cases.
Yes, this is surprisingly low. If the numbers really are true, my conclusion would be that no US broker required the filing of this form before releasing the funds.
Unfortunately the video does not address the topic of the treaties. As far as I understand Bermuda and the US don’t have such a treaty, so it made sense that it was not addressed in the video. Still, he could have chosen another country to illustrate this topic.
Edit: I found a different site than was shown in the video. This site only has data until 2011.
See link in my post, there’s the stats for up to 2014.
In other words IRS estate tax is tax which is not applied to actual funds and exemption form exists only for entertainment purposes?
I find it hard to believe. Most likely there are other reasons
Why would it be hard to believe? All the modern tax treaty with the US put public stock holding out of scope. (Enforcing the tax is also bad for the US hegemony in financial markets)
Afaik the spirit of the tax is more for things like real estate, non public companies or majority ownership.
Also it is trivially avoidable for anyone with large amount of asset (just wrap the assets in a non US shell).
I mean hard to believe that law is not being enforced. If common stock is out of scope then it’s a different matter all together because I think most people most likely use their own country brokers and products for international investing via ETFs.
Thus if real numbers are so low then it can also mean that number of people who fall in scope are also low.
How would that even work? There’s no registry of stock holder since stock is typically held in street name.
In any case, numbers give a clear picture.
And for swiss folks, if you’re under the exemption I don’t think you risk anything, the penalties for not filing/filing late are based on the tax due which is 0 for global assets below 13M. So yes, if your broker doesn’t force you like ibkr or US broker, it’s likely a non issue.
I think how it works is that entity holding your assets need to enforce it. US brokers will. But maybe Swiss brokers will “forget” about it
Yeah it doesn’t look like the US is asking for enforcement. (It’s not part of the QI framework, which makes sense QI is for intermediaries handling dividend payment)
Maybe also because such a tax is so unusual (compared to withholding tax)?
Could be.
So I think for the VT lovers, maybe SQ or Saxo could be a less hassle option. As potentially they might not be enforcing the estate tax compliance
Of course people will only find out when time comes. But atleast something
I understand the thinking, but I am very wary of trusting “law exists, it’s not enforced here”. All you (don’t) need is one zealous bank compliance officer flagging a new risk for a visibility internal play.
I agree. Still, I assume that (almost) every day someone in Switzerland dies with more than 60k in US assets. Nothing visible or audible about major issues.
I’m rooting for the next president to have the IRS reinstate the publication of the numbers of 706-NA filings ![]()
Yeah there’s 70k death per year in CH, 1% with over 60k US assets seems fairly conservative (I mean holding BRKB or AAPL or MSFT used to be fairly popular, and nowadays SPCX or TSLA are).
And that’s only for Switzerland (which is tiny compared to rest of the world)
Probably we’re the only ones interested, but I’m fairly sure a US citizen/resident could get the number through FOIA filing.