Coming up: Partial 3a withdraw

Based on motion " Teilbezug von Vorsorgegeldern ermöglichen" (DE, FR; IT), there is an update as of today:

From 2028, it is expected that partial withdrawals from Pillar 3a will be allowed.

Details: Verordnungsanpassungen zur Umsetzung dreier Motionen im Bereich berufliche Vorsorge: Vernehmlassung eröffnet (DE, FR, IT):

3 Likes

Unfortunately only two withdrawals per account (with the first one >20k CHF). I think it still makes sense to have multiple accounts, but this gives you some additional flexibility (e.g. when you have multiple accounts with different amounts in it), which is nice.

With five accounts that gives you ten withdrawals

Use the first five to pay down the mortgage, another five to get things out of 3a and into your own broker.

Withdraw 200k over ten years for the progression of 20k each year

Sorted

1 Like

Any reason why it’s still limited? Why not completely remove any restrictions on moving 3a money around?

send an email to Andri Silberschmidt, he initiated this - he’d know :slight_smile: let us know what you find

According to the explanations, to minimise the administrative work for the institutions (in my opinion kinda ridiculous, they can charge for that and some already do) and to prevent reducing progression too much by having many smaller withdrawals (wasn’t that the purpose of the whole thing?).

Die Beschränkung auf höchstens zwei Teilbezüge sowie die Festlegung eines Erstbezugsbetrags von mindestens 20`000 verhindert eine übermässige Aufsplittung der Altersleistung und schützt die Einrichtung vor unverhältnismässigem administrativem Aufwand. Zugleich wird damit vermieden, dass durch eine Vielzahl kleiner Teilbezüge die Steuerprogression erheblich gebrochen werden könnte.

1 Like

IMO. Dumb and creates unnecessary admin. It was fine before. People can open up multiple 3a accounts if they want flexibility.

2 Likes

They just started the consultation, things can still evolve.

sorry but you can start to withdraw at 60 and before 65 years, except if they change the rules or that means you will keep a job until 70 years.

“There is no such thing as a free lunch…”

Since I won’t benefit from this for the next ~30 years (I don’t plan to buy a house or self-employment), I wonder: How much tax revenue will be lost?

For 3a I guess close to none (it’s already been fairly well known that it’s preferable to have more than one account).

For vested benefit account, it might allow more staggered withdrawal, but cantons with steeper progression could neutralize it if they want to. (Some cantons have proportional taxation, so no impact).

It doesn’t impact people who are still employed when they retired (which might be the majority at the moment), or the people who did withdrawal for home ownership.

WEF disagrees

The more interesting question is if they add a withdrawal cadence much like the five years that exist for the 2nd pillar

1 Like

From the early-retiree side, I’m curious whether this would also touch vested-benefit accounts, not just 3a. I just stopped working, so my 2nd pillar is moving to vested benefits, and staggering withdrawals over different tax years matters a lot there. If partial withdrawals came to those accounts too, it might reduce the need to split across two foundations. Since it’s only at consultation stage, I’m not changing anything yet. Does anyone know if the proposal covers vested benefits, or how their canton taxes withdrawals spread over several years?

Yes, it’s for both VB and 3a.

There’s no tax change as part of this proposal (taxation of lump sum is a totally different part of the law).

Not really, with the change you can spread over 4y if you split the foundations.

1 Like

I’d split across 2 foundations anyway as you never know what happens in the future.

3 Likes

Ngl, I don’t know which lobby groups are influencing the federal council here, but I don’t understand why we don’t get an unlimited number from withdrawals or a set number of tax deferred withdrawals IN TOTAL - no matter how your accounts are split up or whatever.

The whole “but it’s too much work for the providers” is absolutely laughable. The way it seems to be proposed is needlessly complicated for absolutely no reason and I’d actually prefer today’s solution over the newly created bureaucracy. Like come on - only 2 withdrawals per account, but you can still have 10 accounts… what a joke.

1 Like

limiting the withdrawal number is so dumb. It just doesn‘t make any sense.

So still multiple accounts required to circumvent the restriction.

Why make this needlesly harder than it needs to be lol.

1 Like

Especially because this is another law which needs people and control organs to enforce it… bureaucratic expansion in disguise, nothing more, nothing less… I really hope we get this in order and don’t end up like Germany…

With this new rule, it may make sense to withdraw the funds much earlier, starting from 40 or 50 and reducing the mortgage, so that you actual raw capital withdrawals at 60 become smaller.

2 Likes

I think it’s quite obvious why they’re suggesting this.
To minimize the loss of tax revenue.

If a person with 300K in a single 3a account were allowed to spread their withdrawals over 6 years (60-65y), the government would get a lot less tax revenue from it, than if withdrawals were limited to just two, as suggested now.

If this suggestion goes through, and cantons will for the same reason prefer 2 withdrawals than unlimited, then 5+ 3a accounts will still be the go-to-strategy IMO.

BTW:
Minimizing loss of tax revenue must have been the same reason why they allowed buying into 3a only from 2025 onwards. And why they restricted buy-backs to people who had income subject to AHV contributions in those years.

1 Like

Okay - sure, but then they could’ve just said “max 5 tax years with 3a and max 2 years with 2nd pillar (and vested benefits) withdrawals. Anything over that is added to the last withdrawal year”.

Now your provider needs to check if you already withdrew, you can still do like 10 withdrawals, etc.

Instead of replacing the current unfair system, they created an even more complicated and unfair system… Plus a few needless jobs that need to check that this actually happens IRL. This seems like a worsening, instead of an improvement - as partial withdrawals for self owned RE were allowed anyways…

1 Like