From the WSJ: The Rough Day in Court for Trump’s Tariffs
Summary (courtesy of Gemini):
U.S. judges are challenging President Trump’s use of emergency powers to unilaterally impose tariffs, questioning the legal basis of his actions. The core dispute revolves around whether the 1977 IEEPA law, which doesn’t explicitly mention tariffs, grants the president this broad authority. Judges expressed skepticism, emphasizing that the Constitution assigns tariff power to Congress and that historical precedent doesn’t support the administration’s claims.
Excerpt (on the novelty of the administration’s argument):
“And yet the statute’s been in existence for over 50 years, correct?…Why is that? Has there been no national emergencies in 50 years?” — Judge Jimmie Reyna
Excerpt (on the lack of legal grounding for tariffs within the law):
“‘Tariffs’ seems to have no friends in that statute, so why would we read tariffs into that statute?” — Judge Alan Lourie