While I agree with the first part of your sentence, I have a feeling that the abolition of imputed rental value will in fact slow down price growth, at least for a number of years until the market adjusts itself to the new status
I just checked again, apparently neither UBS, Raiffaisen nor anyone else knows what is really going to happen price wise… I remember reading that the abolishment could have an up to 5% one time positive effect on prices (positive for RE owners
), but my cristal ball isn’t any better than yours ig.
Since owning RE now is more favorable cash flow wise, I do personally not expect a stop in climbing prices.
The thing that really bothers me is the fact that I can’t deduct my margin intrest from 2029 onwards - and I am not really sure why they snuck away this possibility, since debt isn’t only someting RE owners have. Especially painful for people with high intrest personal credit loans.
I think it could be a difference of of “old” RE where a lot of renovations is required, these properties might face actually some more price pressure as there is no incentive anymore to buy these properties as the renovations are not tax deductible. For new RE the situation could be different and these could potentially further increase.
In general I think it will be not good for anybody. Homeowners will not do any renovations unless is absolutely needed which will impact several local companies that lived of the renovations.
Just had a quick look at the buildings stats in Switzerland (2024) and out of just above 1.800.000 buildings/dwellings just over 100k were built 2016 and after.
So some 6% of the buildings will not need works for a few years more and the 94% will slowly lose value as maintenance becomes more costly.
So if the 94% of the park loses attractiveness, it will proportionally drag down also the new builds.
Looks like we are going in for a price correction. I’d be happy to hear different viewpoints ofc
Inflation + growing population > new builds = higher prices
Buy now, or be priced out of the market forever ![]()
There is now an incentive for “Schwarzarbeit” which is very stupid imho. Again, no clue what the electorate thought here… Imho the inputted rental value was quite a moderate and fair way of taxing the “yield” of real estate - the same way yields on accumulating ETFs were taxed.
idk, and a bit off-topic and political, renovations still maintain or upgrade your property. People spend a lot of money on stuff without it being tax deductible.
And businesses manage to survive without indirect tax support and reporting their earnings and paying taxes on them.
It’ll be ok.
Yes and they will continue to do so. Only, they will pay in cash for a discount and the worker will not declare the income and so the state will lose income tax as a result. And honest firms will be outcompeted by the dishonest ones.
that’s a terrible example though, since a company will still be able to deduct renovations
(or any other expenses related to businesses)
It was poorly worded. I meant there will still be demand, without the customers getting a tax deductions. As in, currently the tax deductions might skew the demand, or allow companies to overcharge or work inefficiently.
And that companies and/or customers will mostly continue to play fair. I wouldn’t contract someone to work on my place that suggests I pay them off the books.
I think for your average home owner, the pricing power is in the hands of the contractor, not the owner. Some trades are very difficult to get a hand on as they’re in high demand and suffer from low qualified workers supply.
The clients with pricing power are the institutional owners who have several buildings and are not affected by the change of law so I don’t think the changes will allow to reduce inefficiencies in any way.
Exactly. The point above mine was that contractors will suffer due to lower demand. Maybe they will, a bit, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing overall.
Either way, time will tell. Ideally, there’s even a margin pressure on mortgages (to move back to topic
)
Also hopefully renovation costs will decrease a bit
Second (or third) reincarnation of the topic:
Owner occupiers will gain on removal of imputed rental and lose on interest deduction.
I guess it will not be long before some kind of tax on property is brought into replace Eigenmietwert so will enjoy it while I can!
Was this part of the vote?
and if they bring back some deduction of debt, we’ll come full circle.
Imho the inputted rental value was a very good way to tax real estate ownership - but a property tax would also be good. Taxing real estate is one of the most ideal wealth taxation methods. If applied to self occupied homes only it wouldn’t be damaging to the rental market either.
As an RE owner, I’m fine either way - intrest deduction is nice to have, but not that relevant on my income levels.
They shouldn’t have gotten rid of this in the first place… this was a political apeasment compromise. Reducing demand for rennovations and promoting illegal (and untaxed) work isn’t ideal either…
I agree. It was really good, but hard to explain/sell the advantages to voters.
I always saw it as taxing the “dividend” aka - reduced housing costs portion. We could also tax land or property at a full and real wealth value etc.