About CapTrader

Is anyone actually using https://www.captrader.com/ ? Very few messages mentioning about this broker recently and nothing specific.

Is it because there is nothing to complain about? “No news is good news” case?

Many thanks,
Dr. PI

One downside is that it’s in EU, so no US ETFs by default.

1 Like

https://www.captrader.com/en/payments/deposit-guarantees/

At CapTrader you can, depending on your permanent residence

  • open an account in Ireland if your permanent residence is within the EU (EEA) - IBIE
  • open an UK account if your permanent residence is outside the EU (EEA) - IBUK

Do you have your permanent residence outside the EU (EEA) and live, for example, in Switzerland, Liechtenstein, Russia or Great Britain? Then please click here to go to the deposit insurance information page for the IBUK Account.

Liechtenstein is actually in EEA. So it would be to good have a feedback from people with an actual experience.

1 Like

Looking at their contract, it seems that they use Interactive Brokers services. They act as intermediary.

I don’t see the advantage of adding “a middle man”. I would open an account directly with IB.

https://www.captrader.com/en/account/live-account/

2 Likes

Yes they are.

Avoiding monthly fee from IB.

I might, but first I want to check available options.

And for now this is my preferred option.

Different pricing - no minimum commission.

https://www.captrader.com/en/account/commissions/

Their commissions pricing looks similar to the “Fixed” option available at IB. Same pricing on several markets, more expensive on other (i.e Switzerland with a higher minimum), while other have no maximum (i.e. maximum of EUR 29 for the French market on IB).

The US market is twice as expensive on captrader. They charge 1 cent per share with a minimum of USD 2 (maximum 1%). IB will charge half a cent per share with a minimum of USD 1, maximum 1%.

Their forex commissions are higher too at capetrader (higher spread and minimum order).

Not sure it’s cheaper at the end. What is saved in activity fee (IB USD 10 less commissions) would be spend elsewhere with capetrader.

Where? I need 1-2, max 3 transactions (US, maybe EU, definitely not CH) per month.

Ok, it is a microoptimization, but still I am curious to know other’s experience.

Higher commissions on trades and FX with captrader.

Does it worth the few dollars saved every month? That’s up to you. Using Swissquote these days, you shouldn’t be afraid of USD 10/month (less commissions) on IB.

I’m not convinced this kind of penny savings will make a difference in a long term investor journey.

If after your comparison and trades simulation, this platform is cheaper than IB, that’s good for you.

I also read the same question in a discord group.
This YouTuber (that normally makes serious reviews) posted this video on CapTrader.
Anyone has any experience?

Avoid IB monthly fees and Degiro’s fees on distributing dividends seem to be 2 strong reasons to try it (as a second basket for the eggs?!).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Od4VrplwB-8

Well, no, it is the same basket as IB, just differently decorated.

2 Likes

True. It was a Degiro’s perspective input :slight_smile:

… Only 2 reviews at Trustpilot for a company founded in 1997.

So, I have opened an account with CapTrader.

They clearly targeting DACH customers. The web site has more content in German, including translated docs of Interactive Brokers. “Germany, Austria, Switzerland” were three preselected options to select the country of residence.

My account was opened at IBUK. I don’t think it is their decision, this is IB that decides where customers with a specific residence will be registered. After filling a lengthy account opening form at captrader.com, I got a message that an account at IB will be opened for me now. After waiting for few days, I had to fill few more things already at IB website and transfer funds. I did CHF transfer, the destination was IB’s account, not CapTrader’s.

So now I have a Uxxxxx account at IB “managed” by CapTrader. The “Account Information” says:
Master Name CapTrader GmbH
Account Type Broker Client

“Managing” means that I pay higher fees than at IB itself, but there is no inactivity fee. I expect a very smooth transition to “plain” IB, which makes sense, of course, if one has > 100k USD.

After I transferred CHF to my IBUK account, I bought VT (fee 2 USD) and exchanged CHF to USD (fee 3.75 USD).

That’s it.

It’s IB’s interface?
You transfer in CHF? The balance is shown in CHF? And he converts when you invest?
(I’m looking for solutions to avoid Degiro’s fees on dividends.) Thanks for the feedback on CapTrader.

How would I know :slight_smile: ? I can login at https://www.interactivebrokers.co.uk/, so far I used “Client Portal”. Their app is showing that it is connected to servers at ibllc.com.

Yes. Credited in the morning of the transfer day.

I chose USD as a base currency to be able to convert everything to USD and have fees debited in USD.

No, this you do yourself.

1 Like

This thread is now obsolete: a “direct” IB account (Account Type: Individual) has lower commission than CapTrader and no inactivity fees anymore.

The only reason to become CapTrader client now is if you absolutely need support in German.

1 Like
By reading and partipating to this forum, you confirm you have read and agree with the disclaimer presented on http://www.mustachianpost.com/
En lisant et participant à ce forum, vous confirmez avoir lu et être d'accord avec l'avis de dégagement de responsabilité présenté sur http://www.mustachianpost.com/fr/